Dolly Parton Can Wear What She Wants

THE LEORA LETTER

December 14, 2023

I research and write about slut-shaming to raise awareness about the harm it causes. When people are dismissed as sluts, hoes, and thots, they are denied care and compassion as human beings and in a variety of situations, including when they are sexually harassed, sexually assaulted, victimized by image-based sexual abuse ("revenge porn"), and need an abortion.

Music legend Dolly Parton, 77, dressed as a Dallas Cowboys cheerleader during a halftime performance on Thanksgiving. It was a cheeky, humorous move—and most fans loved it.


“She’s rocking that outfit” and “SHE ABSOLUTELY KILLED IT!” were among the comments.


Others said,  “I love her but I don’t want to see her in a cheerleading outfit” and that she should act her age.


USA Today weighed in, noting that the negative comments were driven by ageism. And, of course, sexism played a big role.


The article quoted me saying, “When you're younger, the pressure is to look sexy, to look hot. As you get older, and you age out of those pressures and expectations, you're still supposed to conform to a very narrow set of rules and guidelines that are never really spelled about what you're supposed to look like physically."


If you know me and my work, this quote is not particularly notable; it's the kind of statement I provide reporters regularly. What made this one unusual is that the reporter had not in fact reached out to me to ask for my response about Dolly Parton. Instead, she recycled a quote I had provided for a previous USA Today article on Dr. Jill Biden and Diane Keaton, published in 2021. Biden, then 69, had been criticized for dressing “inappropriately” for her age when she wore patterned tights, while Keaton, then 75, had worn thigh-high boots.


In other words: Nothing has changed, and reporters can safely reuse quotes from years-old stories about gendered ageism without incident. It's the same story, but with a new protagonist. (To be clear, I don't find fault with the reporter for reusing the quote. It was a smart move because the quote fit the Dolly Parton story seamlessly and enabled the article to go live quickly on a holiday.)


Here’s what I told USA Today last time, and it applies to us all: Older women "should just own [their look]: 'This is who I am. This is what I decided to put on this morning. This is what I look like. Deal with it.'”


And if next time the subject of the story is an older woman of color having fun with fashion or costume, she will be at greater risk of judgment because of the stereotype that women of color are more sexually available than White women. Looking "appropriate" means different things depending on who you are.

Dolly Parton dressed as a Dallas Cowboys cheerleader, Thanksgiving 2023
MORE INFORMATION ON SLUT SHAMING

“Boys will be boys, and girls will be sluts.” — Leora Tanenbaum

Share by: